Sunday 15 November , 2026 | 10:17

Transitions and the Institutionalization of Revolutionary Politics

14 November, 2026

First published in COR-digital

In this article, we will attempt to analyze the transitions in the historical processes of class struggle during this period, characterized by the decomposition of imperialism and the catastrophic assimilation of former workers’ States. To do so, we draw upon the Theory of Permanent Revolution and the specific tasks for revolutionaries that emerge from it.

We must start from this premise: the Russian Revolution of 1917 not only altered the global situation but also sophisticated the strategy and tactics of revolutionaries, as it elevated political and economic transitions to a new level. That means that the main hypothesis was no longer something along the lines of the Paris Commune or a “late February”, but rather a triumphant revolution led by a revolutionary party as the leadership of a workers’ vanguard. This revolution set in motion a series of transitions: to a workers’ state and then to a non-State. In other words, it ushered in the stage of transition from socialism to communism and the growing over from socialist revolution into world revolution. It opened a historical period—not yet closed—in which revolutionaries’ working hypothesis was based on violating the law of value, implementing economic planning and organizing the economy on new social foundations. And in this, they did not limit themselves to the territory of the USSR but sought ways to generalize that experience. This revolutionary feat—which the leaderships of these processes embodied in the programs of the Internationals, such as the Third International before its Stalinization and the Fourth International with its Transitional Program—should be the point where we pick up the thread and keep up developing our politics in order to set forth the guidelines for the reconstruction of the Fourth International.

Past revolutions have bequeathed historical lessons, drawing these lessons implies that the preparation of the future ones must build upon the most advanced achievements of these previous processes and not step back to historical situations that have already been overcome and incorporated into those revolutionary transitions. In other words: the Commune (carried out by the working class during the phase of capitalist expansion), as a historical experience, was superseded by the early Soviets (the outcome of the new relationship established between the workers’ vanguard and the bourgeoisie during the imperialist phase). Upon the creation of Soviets, the revolutionary development reached a synthesis by creating the Soviet system of the dictatorship of the proletariat, which was approached from a permanentist perspective (within an international dynamic). The dictatorship of the proletariat was established as a form of State, within the Federations as an economic units. And in that process, the party also assumes its permanent character within the stages of the dictatorship of the proletariat and as a world party—the Internationals. All this means that we must incorporate into the historical process the strategy and tactics that arise from it.

In our analysis of the Russian Revolution and its transition our starting point is the most advanced stage that this process reached. We don’t consider correct to fall into analogies with events previous to that revolution when analyzing the current processes of class struggle, because it means that the lessons of that process are being ignored. By doing so, historical materialism is being abandoned, and it misleads the workers’ vanguard into confusion regarding the specific tasks it faces in the imperialist epoch of crisis, wars and revolutions. In this epoch, the material relations between the working class and the imperialist bourgeoisies and their States have a particular character that is completely different from the experiences prior to World War I. Equating transitions that correspond to such different historical periods confuses and disarms the vanguard both programmatically and organizationally. This confusion is not innocent: ultimately, it promotes the idea of a “democratic” bourgeoisie, already extinct in the epoch of capitalism’s decomposition. From this perspective, the argument that we have not witnessed any successful revolutions in recent years—and that we must therefore draw on earlier periods to attempt to recreate a similar situation—is false.

When Trotsky set out to generalize the Russian experience, he did so on the basis of the method of historical materialism—which is entirely opposed to the idea that it is a manual or an infallible recipe. Marx (1844), when analyzing the role of the proletariat in the revolution, argued that the proletariat organizes a “dominant group within society at the cost of society.” This is a revolutionary transition of a class within bourgeois society that “does not belong to bourgeois society.” Picking
up the thread, Trotsky defined one of the most important lessons of the Russian Revolution as the “invasion of the workers’ state in capitalist society” (Trotsky, 1924) —that is, the “organization of a dominant group at the cost of bourgeois society”—as a generalization of the proletariat’s revolutionary transition. This dynamic of the relationship between classes in revolutionary processes must be incorporated into 21st-century revolutionary tactics. This implies battling against any sociological or politicist view that centers its analysis of revolutions on petty-bourgeois movements rather than on the potential of the proletariat.

Let us recall that in the period following the Russian Revolution, we Trotskyists debated the postwar revolutionary processes and the characteristics of their leaderships, which gave rise to deformed or degenerated workers’ States. From this arose the task of seeking the triumph of complementary revolutions within those processes, to halt and defeat the leaderships that were leading them toward capitalist restorations. At that time, the debate on the transition centered on the development of the dictatorship of the proletariat at the national level and its international extension—that is, its permanentist scope. The heart of the matter passed through the relationship between revolutionary processes, leaderships, and parties. The defeats of those revolutions and the formation of counterrevolutionary leaderships—such as Stalinism, Maoism, Castroism, Titoism, and others—moved away the concept of revolution and the idea of the dictatorship of the proletariat. Perhaps one of the last opportunities for a workers’ and socialist revolution was the Carnation Revolution in ’74 or the near-revolutionary political processes in the former workers’ states of the 1980s.

Faced with these difficulties—and in search of shortcuts—many Trotskyist leaders overestimated the role of the petty bourgeoisie and ascribed to it a revolutionary role it didn’t have. After May ‘68 in France, the Trotskyists’ discussion centered on the relationship between the movements and the party, and they sought to reexamine possible transitions without a revolutionary horizon. Here, their analysis of the situation stepped away from the Marxist theory—which was reduced to the level of mere philosophical debates and sidelining the economic analysis, which is the core of the theory. For example, all sorts of “Marxisms” emerged for the analysis of partial aspects of capitalist society—either culture, art, alienation, or forms of oppression—while dismissing any analysis of the economic structure (and thus of social classes) as “economism” or “class reductionism.” Once again we insist on the point that making analyses and drawing conclusions within the realm of culture—or, rather, of politics understood as cultural relations instead of concentrated economics—was not innocent; indeed, it sought to eradicate the idea of insurrection as an art, the idea of a Leninist party, and of economic planning, in order to make way for a watered-down Marxism, compatible with academic and parliamentarian trends.

There was a shift from leaning on the concept of the dictatorship of the proletariat and its three stages (disorganizing the bourgeoisie, organizing the proletariat, and preparing the stages of the dictatorship) to focus on “hegemony,” diluting the class within social movements and seeking to press partial demands on States in the name of securing more rights. They set aside the task of destroying the State in order to pursue a policy of redistributing accumulation. Thus, it came up a theory in which the (bourgeois) State would play a progressive role, namely, that of guaranteeing the social reproduction of our class where the law of value supposedly does not operate. Hence the emphasis on identity-based, environmental, and other movements against oppression, because, as the postmodernists used to say, they were “beyond the law of value.” They institutionalized revolutionary politics by bringing it into the state superstructure of bourgeois society and lost sight of the target of attacking production as the foundation of the bourgeois class. In this way, they stripped the Transitional Program of all its revolutionary cutting edge.

For some sectors of Morenoism (from Nahuel Moreno’s current) the emergence of the radicalized petty bourgeoisie led them theorize on the possibility of change within the political regime: a “democratic revolution,” as a necessary stage for revolution. The heirs of Morenoism attempt to refine their mentor’s theory by elevating the category of “democratic revolution” —no longer to the political regime, but to the State itself. In this way, social movements exert pressure on the State and can destabilize it, whether through parliamentary means or through the pressure of cross-class movements. The leading representative of this “post-Morenoism” is the PTS in Argentina. E. Albamonte and M. Maiello (2017, p. 560) criticize “theories such as that of Nahuel Moreno, who understood democratic revolutions as ‘revolutions within regimes’ (but not within the State).” And they base on this their assessment of “the importance that the radical-democratic program takes on at present, which seeks to accelerate the masses’ experience with their illusions in capitalist democracy, undermine bourgeois hegemony, and facilitate the transition from a defensive to an offensive position in the struggle for workers’ power” (Ibid., p. 562).

Invasion of Workers’ State in Capitalist Society

Let us pause for a moment to try to explain what this elaboration by Trotsky (1924) means to us and what its implications are. First, we must point out that it proposes a different approach to preparing for revolutionary processes—no longer based on analogies from the period before the Russian Revolution, but rather on the generalization of revolutionary practices in the transition from the Russian Revolution to world revolution. This explanation is important, because without it, we cannot understand the Transitional Program or the programmatic developments of the Third International, which call for the destruction of the bourgeois State through a more concrete program of action. Let’s look at some examples. The Soviet is no longer confined to the framework of being considered a democratic organism where we can discuss freely (as some centrists claim). While this is an important aspect, the formation of Soviets as a preparatory step must be conceived within the Soviet system, which is not simply a form of government that can be compared abstractly to a parliamentary system; it is, above all, a new way of relationship with property. Lenin (1918) spoke of Soviet power as the organized form of the dictatorship of the proletariat—the dictatorship of the vanguard class that ushers in a new democracy and independent participation in the government of the State. The development of Soviet organization represents a higher form of democracy—a breakup with bourgeois distortions of democracy—and the transition to socialist democracy and to the conditions under which the State can begin to wither away. In this way, Soviet democracy in Russia constituted a leap over bourgeois democracy, which was impossible to develop during the imperialist epoch. This is the specific transition from which we pick up the thread when we place action to form a workers’ vanguard that understands the significance of the formation of Soviets. Workers’ control, sliding scales of working hours and wages, cannot be viewed as anti-crisis measures, but rather as a preparation for the future transitional system of labor on the path toward the abolition of the wage labor system and the violation of the law of value through planning—which is the conscious intervention of a revolutionary leadership in the bourgeois economy. The idea of expanding the functions of labor unions (under revolutionary leadership) must move in this direction.

Destroying capitalist society presupposes a plan, which involves fighting to progressively replace the market-based models of social organization with criteria for the planned allocation of resources. In this transition—which cannot take place without a workers’ and socialist revolution (because we must destroy the State and dissolve the old social relations)—preparation must set these objectives as its guiding principle. Preparing the cadres and the party for this challenge is also a political struggle against centrism, which places the preparation tasks at a stage prior to the Russian Revolution and disregards post-revolutionary transition.

We revolutionaries are aware that class struggle is ultimately the struggle for surplus value, and this conception entails a life-and-death struggle to destroy the laws of capital and its fundamental law, which is the law of value. In this historical period, it is necessary to seek the invasion of the workers’ State in capitalist society in order to destroy the value-system of capitalist economy—which is a vast system of spontaneous social accounting—and to organize labor on new social foundations. For centrists, the struggle is about redistributing profits, and they situate the struggle within the level of capitalist accumulation — that is, they withdraw from the sphere of production to seek solutions to this inequality within bourgeois states. That is why we say they institutionalize revolutionary policies: by reducing them to mere stages, they blunt their cutting edge and deprive them of any idea of transition.

Learning lessons from the past, preparing for the future

This reverse evolutionism on the part of certain sectors of Trotskyist centrism seeks to resolve, through analogies, the age-old question—repeated ad nauseam by postwar Trotskyism—of what to do with the petty bourgeoisie.

This fixation of centrism on the middle classes can be explained by their significant growth, especially after World War II, and their influence on reformist parliamentarism. However, Trotsky would point out, several years earlier, the contradiction between the petty bourgeoisie’s growing numerical importance and its diminishing importance in production (Trotsky, 1920).

An organization that understands the need to conceptualize the program from the perspective of production rather than from political superstructure—instead of asking what to do with the middle classes—must ask itself how to organize the concentrated proletariat.

The approach of basing the program on the political superstructure inevitably leads to an ahistorical defense of the Constituent Assembly tactic at all times and in all places. But one might ask whether, in the current epoch of capitalist decomposition, such a Constituent Assembly could play any progressive role at all. After all, the obsolescence of the Constituent Assembly, its consequent dismantling, and the development of the Soviet system in its place was, for the Bolsheviks, an inevitable consequence of imperialism and war.

The eagerness to replace the revolutionary program with the struggle for democratic rights and freedoms, the institutionalization of political practice in Parliament, and posing the idea of a Constituent Assembly as an “arbitrator” where the country’s fate would be decided—along with reevaluations of pre-Soviet revolutionary experiences, the search for “new revolutionary subjects,” etc.— are strong indicators that, at present, a significant sector of Trotskyist centrism is preparing to programmatically abandon the dictatorship of the proletariat.

The political experiences of the petty bourgeoisie in imperialist countries and their failed experiments, such as Podemos or Syriza, dealt a severe blow to centrist currents. But far from drawing conclusions that would bring them closer to a revolutionary perspective, they succumbed to skepticism and limited their practice to making demands on the bourgeois State. The proletariat, meanwhile, adds to its sufferings the consequences of imperialism’s growing economic concentration and its ensuing decline, on a path toward inevitable warmongering. The task of the vanguard is not to seek theoretical shortcuts. The centrists search for analogies in the history of class struggle as if looking for a missing sock in a drawer. Rather, it is a matter of upholding the Marxist method to draw lessons from the past and prepare to confront imperialist war, transforming it into victorious insurrections that will open the path for building socialism.

 

References

Marx, K. (1844), “Critical Notes on the Article: ‘The King of Prussia and Social Reform.’ By a Prussian”

Albamonte, E. and Maiello, M. (2017), Estrategia socialista y arte militar, Ediciones IPS, Argentina.

Lenin, V. I. (1918), Las tareas inmediatas del poder soviético, obras completas XXVIII, Cartago, Buenos Aires, pág. 479 y 480.

Trotsky, L. (1920),“Communism and Terrorism”.

Trotsky, L. (1924), “The Lessons of October.” The actual quote reads as follow: “a purely socialist invasion of the workers’ state into the sphere of capitalist property rights.”

MORE NEWS
arrow-left-circlearrow-right-circlechevron-up-circle